Between Promise and Appropriation: A Systematic Budget Analysis of Pakistan’s Constitutional Obligation to Safeguard Minority Rights Across Federal and Provincial Governments (2021–22 to 2025–26)

Abstract

Pakistan’s Constitution obligates the state to safeguard the rights of its religious minorities, who constitute approximately 3.5 to 4 percent of the national population. However, this declaratory guarantee has historically lacked an empirically testable fiscal benchmark, leaving the operational reality of minority welfare provisioning largely unexamined across multiple tiers of government. This study aims to operationalize the constitutional mandate as a measurable standard. It seeks to systematically extract, classify, and compare minority-directed public expenditure in Pakistan across the federal and four provincial governments (Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and Balochistan). It does so over a five-year period (2021–22 to 2025–26), while identifying structural mechanisms of fiscal exclusion.

A mixed-methods documentary analysis was employed to audit official demand-for-grant schedules and budget publications. Line items were categorized using a standardized four-category coding scheme. The analysis integrated real-terms inflation adjustments, geographic-demographic correspondence mapping utilizing census data, and triangulation against an independent human rights conditions baseline.

The audit reveals a severe real-terms contraction in federal minority-directed spending alongside profound spatial inequalities, epitomized by Sindh concentrating over 96 percent of its dedicated fund in two urban divisions. Crucially, budget architecture actively forecloses constitutional compliance verification. This is demonstrated by the absence of demographic tracking in mainstream sector budgets and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s structural misclassification of nearly two billion rupees of majority-serving stipends under the minority affairs functional code. Furthermore, state allocations remain entirely disconnected from documented crises of communal violence.

Budgetary opacity and administrative inertia operate as primary mechanisms of fiscal exclusion, rendering constitutional promises functionally unverifiable. Meaningful reform requires formula-based geographic sub-allocations, functional code separation, and mandatory demographic disaggregation in mainstream public financial management.

Classification: Public Finance / Development Studies / Minority Rights

References

Anthony, G. M. N., & Arslan, M. (2020). Effectiveness of local government systems, pro-poor budgeting, and policies for marginalized communities. Pakistan Social Sciences Review, 4(3). https://pssr.org.pk/issues/v4/3/effectiveness-of-local-government-systems-pro-poor-budgeting-and-policies-for-marginalized-communities.pdf

Asif, M. (2025). Fiscal federalism in Pakistan: A critical analysis of the National Finance Commission Award and resource distribution among provinces. Pakistan Journal of Social Science Review, 4(5), 803–813. https://pjssrjournal.com/index.php/Journal/article/view/247/241

Bowen, G. A. (2009). Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qualitative Research Journal, 9(2), 27–40. https://doi.org/10.3316/QRJ0902027

Din, N., & Jacob, P. (2019). Challenges in exercising religious freedom in Pakistan. Centre for Social Justice. https://csjpak.org/publications/Study-Challenges-in-Exercising-Religious-Freedom-in-Pakistan-CSJ.pdf

Gazdar, H., Masood, S. Q., & Naqvi, H. (2013). Bottom up or top down? Exclusion and citizenship in Pakistan. International Household Survey Network. https://www.old.researchcollective.org/Documents/Bottom_Up_or_Top_Down_Final%20Report.pdf

Ghaus-Pasha, A. (2012). Making devolution work in Pakistan. Lahore School of Economics. https://repository.lahoreschool.edu.pk/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/6032/Making%20Devolution%20Work%20in%20Pakistan.pdf

Gopang, A. M., Katohar, I. A., & Ali, J. (2026). Religious minorities in Pakistan: Constitutional rights, social realities, and the quest for inclusive citizenship. Journal of Religion and Society, 5(1), 600–612. https://islamicreligious.com/index.php/Journal/article/download/459/594/645

Government of Balochistan, Finance Department. (2025). Budget estimates 2025–2026: Grant BC21064 (Minorities affairs department). https://balochistan.gov.pk/budget-past-five-years

Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Finance Department. (2021). Demands for grants 2021–2022. https://www.finance.gkp.pk/articles/budget/budget-estimates/budget-estimates-2021-22

Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Finance Department. (2022). Demands for grants 2022–2023. https://www.finance.gkp.pk/articles/budget/budget-estimates/budget-estimates-2022-23

Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Finance Department. (2023). Demands for grants 2023–2024. https://www.finance.gkp.pk/articles/budget/budget-estimates/budget-estimates-2023-24

Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Finance Department. (2024). Demands for grants 2024–2025. https://www.finance.gkp.pk/articles/budget/budget-estimates/budget-estimates-2024-25

Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Finance Department. (2025). Demands for grants 2025–2026. https://www.finance.gkp.pk/articles/budget/budget-estimates/budget-estimates-2025-26

Government of Pakistan, Finance Division. (2021). Federal budget 2021–2022: Details of demands for grants and appropriations, current and development expenditure. https://www.finance.gov.pk/fb_2021_22.html

Government of Pakistan, Finance Division. (2022). Federal budget 2022–2023: Details of demands for grants and appropriations, current and development expenditure. https://www.finance.gov.pk/fb_2022_23.html

Government of Pakistan, Finance Division. (2023). Federal budget 2023–2024: Details of demands for grants and appropriations, current and development expenditure. https://www.finance.gov.pk/fb_2023_24.html

Government of Pakistan, Finance Division. (2024). Federal budget 2024–2025: Details of demands for grants and appropriations, current and development expenditure. https://www.finance.gov.pk/fb_2024_25.html

Government of Pakistan, Finance Division. (2025). Federal budget 2025–2026: Details of demands for grants and appropriations, current and development expenditure. https://www.finance.gov.pk/fb_2025_26.html

Government of the Punjab, Finance Department. (2021). Estimates of charged expenditure and demands for grants 2021–2022. https://finance.punjab.gov.pk/details/annual-budget

Government of the Punjab, Finance Department. (2022). Estimates of charged expenditure and demands for grants 2022–2023. https://finance.punjab.gov.pk/details/annual-budget

Government of the Punjab, Finance Department. (2023). Estimates of charged expenditure and demands for grants 2023–2024. https://finance.punjab.gov.pk/details/annual-budget

Government of the Punjab, Finance Department. (2024). Estimates of charged expenditure and demands for grants 2024–2025. https://finance.punjab.gov.pk/details/annual-budget

Government of the Punjab, Finance Department. (2025). Estimates of charged expenditure and demands for grants 2025–2026. https://finance.punjab.gov.pk/details/annual-budget

Government of Sindh, Finance Department. (2021). Budget estimates 2021–2022: Grant SC21147 (Minorities affairs). https://finance.gos.pk/Budget/VolumeIIIDetail

Government of Sindh, Finance Department. (2022). Budget estimates 2022–2023: Grant SC21147 (Minorities affairs). https://finance.gos.pk/Budget/VolumeIIIDetail2223

Government of Sindh, Finance Department. (2023). Budget estimates 2023–2024: Grant SC21147 (Minorities affairs). https://finance.gos.pk/Budget/VolumeIIIDetail2324

Government of Sindh, Finance Department. (2024). Budget 2024–2025: Grant SC21147 (Minorities affairs). https://finance.gos.pk/Budget/VolumeIIIDetail2425

Government of Sindh, Finance Department. (2025). Budget 2025–2026: Grant SC21147 (Minorities affairs). https://finance.gos.pk/Budget/VolumeIIIDetail2526

Hasan, Z., & Kamil, M. (2025). The Sachar Committee Report: A socio-legal analysis of Muslim marginalisation, state policy, and constitutional equality in India. SSRN. https://ssrn.com/abstract=6084566

Iqtidar, H. (2012). State management of religion in Pakistan and dilemmas of citizenship. Citizenship Studies, 16(8), 1013–1028. https://doi.org/10.1080/13621025.2012.735026

Islam, S. (2025). A systematic review of public budgeting strategies in developing economies: Tools for transparent fiscal governance. American Journal of Advanced Technology and Engineering Solutions, 1(1), 602–635. https://doi.org/10.63125/wm547117

Jaffrelot, C., & Kalaiyarasan, A. (2023). Post-Sachar Indian Muslims: Facets of socio-economic decline. In T. Fazal, D. Vaid, & S. S. Jodhka (Eds.), Marginalities and mobilities among India's Muslims: Elusive citizenship (pp. 19–41). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003280309

Kashif-ul-Huda. (2009). How not to do minority welfare. Economic and Political Weekly, 44(9), 19–21.

Mehboob, F. (2025). Religious pluralism and minority rights in Pakistan: A contemporary analysis. Policy Journal of Social Science Review, 3(8), 56–76. https://policyjssr.com/index.php/PJSSR/article/view/414/404

Mir, Z. A. (2025). Challenges of social policy financing in Pakistan: Evidence from NFC allocations and provincial expenditure patterns. SSRN. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.5816502

Mirjat, R. B. (2023). Minority rights with reference to judicial precedents in Pakistan. European Journal of Economics, Law and Politics, 10(2), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.19044/elp.v10no2a1

National Commission for Human Rights. (2022). Minority report. https://nchr.gov.pk/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Minority-Report-compressed.pdf

National Commission for Human Rights. (2024). Risk of sanitation work in Pakistan report. https://nchr.gov.pk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Risk_of_Sanitation_work_in_pakistan_Report.pdf

Patras, A. I. (2024). Examining Pakistan's relationship with religious minorities: A case study of the Christian community. NUST Journal of International Peace & Stability, 7(1), 80–94. https://doi.org/10.37540/njips.v7i1.163

Ranjah, Z. U. (2020). Protection of the right to freedom of religion or belief in Pakistan. In The Asian Yearbook of Human Rights and Humanitarian Law (pp. 310–329). Brill Nijhoff. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004431768_014

Sammi, A., Rehman, T. U., & Syed, S. A. (2024). Legal context of minority rights in Pakistan. Al-Mahdi Research Journal (MRJ), 5(4), 815–836. https://ojs.mrj.com.pk/index.php/MRJ/article/view/513/652

South Asia Collective. (2022). South Asia state of minorities report 2022: Weakening human rights commitments and its impact on minorities. Minority Rights Group International. https://minorityrights.org/app/uploads/2023/12/sasm2022.pdf

Tabassum, A., & Bakht, N. (2023). Socio-economic status of minorities of Punjab: A critical analysis of Christians. Journal of Politics and International Studies, 6(2). http://111.68.103.26/journals/index.php/jpis/article/viewFile/6766/3474

Tadros, M., Aderounmu, O. A., Aqeel, A., Ahmed, M., Kaye, M. F., Gill, M., & Vanwing, T. (2022). What about us? Global perspectives on redressing religious inequalities. Institute of Development Studies.

Ullah, S., Abbas, A., & Khan, U. (2025). Religion as a political instrument: Comparing state assimilationist strategies in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) and Balochistan. Religions, 16(7), Article 864. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel16070864

United States Commission on International Religious Freedom. (2024). Annual report 2024: Pakistan. https://www.uscirf.gov/sites/default/files/2024-05/2024%20Pakistan.pdf

United States Commission on International Religious Freedom. (2025). Annual report 2025: Pakistan. https://www.uscirf.gov/sites/default/files/2025-04/Pakistan%202025%20USCIRF%20Annual%20Report.pdf

United States Commission on International Religious Freedom. (2026). Annual report 2026: Pakistan. https://www.uscirf.gov/sites/default/files/2026-04/USCIRF%202026%20Annual%20Report%20Pakistan.pdf